Quote:
Originally Posted by icenine
Translation: racism is ok as long as I nor my family is not the target.
|
And therein lies the evidence that close-mindedness is stifling legitimate discourse. Since when does "non-PC" = racism? Answer - it does not. Its more often than not a legitimate difference of opinion. But since some folks - typically those on the "PC" side of the argument - are not tolerant of differences of opinion, they demonize.
S0, suggesting that we need to get a handle on illegal immigration - even if it means barring entry of individuals who hail from parts of the world that are openly hostile to the United States (hmmm...wonder if that needs to include Saudi Arabia now..?) might make some sense. Its exactly the type of policies that are under consideration in European countries right now, so why shouldn't the US also consider better protection of our own borders? Is it racist to suggest that we need to examine our border enforcement / illegal immigration issues? Absolutely not.
When Trump calls ILLEGAL aliens murders and rapists, is this racist? Well, its not exactly PC to say it the way Trump said it. Doesn't make if false, though. Texas, for example, tracks data on arrests and convictions of illegal aliens:
https://www.txdps.state.tx.us/admini...Conviction.pdf
Certainly appears to be some "murdering and raping" going on according to this data. Is it "racist" to point out that illegal immigrants, many of whom are "non-white" like Trump, are engaging in "murdering and raping"? Nope. It appears to be a factual statement.
Is this a higher or lower rate of criminal activity compared to the overall US population? I'd suggest that this is difficult to ascertain, because while the US gov't can and does deport illegal aliens with criminal backgrounds in their home countries, the US can't "deport" individuals with criminal backgrounds who are citizens. This may tend to skew the comparisons a bit.
However, here are some interesting numbers CNN put together:
http://www.cnn.com/2015/07/08/politi...igrants-crime/
You can cherry - pick this a bit, and I'm sure some will. Here's one that jumps out at me:
"73,665
The number of inmates in state and federal prisons who are not U.S. citizens, according to the latest prison population report from the Bureau of Judicial Statistics. That's about 5% of the total prison population."
Estimates put illegal immigrants at about 3 - 3.5% of the US population. Since the US government has the ability to deport illegal immigrants with criminal records - and the effect this would likely have on "stacking the statistical deck" in favor of the illegal immigrant population - the 5% prison population seems a bit larger than it should otherwise be if illegals committed crimes at the same rate as US citizens. Is it "racist" to make this observation. Nope. Its an opinion that is supported by an examination of the available data.
Does this suggest a bias that all illegal immigrants are individuals who are predisposed to be criminals, and are predisposed as a function of their "non-whiteness"? Nope, not even close.
Is the Mexican government "sending" its "criminals" across the border to the US, or "emptying its jails" and sending the "criminals" to the US? I have no idea, but weird things do happen from time to time:
http://worldnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2...near-us-border
There are individuals, including Trump, who suggest that this is exactly what the Mexican government is doing. I seriously doubt that the Mexican government would admit to doing this even if they were, so we may never know for sure. Does it make one a "racist" to speculate about this? Hardly.
But be close-minded if you must. Its a free country and its your God-Given right to be....
Oops. Didn't mean to make a religious reference. Sorry.